Are you planning a romantic getaway in Door County, Wisconsin, and looking for the best Sister Bay restaurants? Then look no further!

Sister Bay has some of the best restaurants that Door County has to offer. Whether you want a cozy diner at fine restaurants that have been featured on Food Network or you prefer a pub and a burger, you will find some of the best options in Sister Bay, Wisconsin.

Sister Bay’s diverse selection of eateries have something for everyone. From casual pubs to upscale bistros, these Sister Bay restaurants will make your vacation unforgettable!

We have visited Door County many times and have personally enjoyed numerous Sister Bay Restaurants. We highly recommend Sister Bay restaurants for couples looking to experience the best that Door County offers.

Here are some of our favorite Sister Bay Restaurants for couples on vacation.

This post may contain affiliate or sponsored links. If you click on a link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission (at no additional cost to you). Please see my full disclosure policy for details

Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant and Butik

If you’re seeking a unique and charming dining experience, then look no further than this Scandinavian Restaurant. This cozy eatery in the heart of Sister Bay serves classic Swedish fare such as Swedish pancakes, meatballs, and other traditional dishes.

In addition to the authentic Swedish meals at Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant, I’m sure you have heard talk about their goats. The famous restaurant has an extra special attraction you don’t want to miss. When you’re looking for some extra fun after your meal, stick around and enjoy watching their famous goats on the roof!

From home, you can visit the Goat Cam to get a closer look at these friendly critters. With its charming atmosphere, delicious food, and unique attractions, Al Johnson’s is an excellent choice for couples looking to experience good food, fun, and uniqueness.

We can’t resist! This is a favorite of ours. Every time we visit Door County, we make a stop at Al Johnson’s for Swedish pancakes and to watch the goats.

Address ~ 10698 N. Shore Dr., Sister Bay

The Waterfront Restaurant

The Waterfront Restaurant is the perfect spot if you are looking for a romantic and upscale dining experience in Sister Bay. The Waterfront Restaurant has some of the most amazing sunsets you will ever see.

This chic restaurant offers stunning views of Sister Bay and the surrounding area, with tables overlooking the water. Inside, you’ll find an elegant atmosphere with plush chairs and chandeliers.

The menu includes a variety of seafood dishes such as crab cakes, salmon, and more. Whether you’re looking for a special occasion or just a night out on the town, The Waterfront Restaurant is sure to make your Sister Bay trip one to remember.

Address ~ 10947 State Hwy 42, Sister Bay

Grasse’s Grill

Grasse’s Grill is a Sister Bay restaurant that is perfect for couples looking for an unforgettable dining experience.

This cozy eatery has a limited menu that offers comfort food with a twist. The sandwiches are creative with excellent taste. The soup is amazing and customers have been heard saying they have the best burgers they have ever eaten.

The menu features gourmet burgers and other delicious dishes. You will enjoy the inviting atmosphere of this Sister Bay restaurant and its convenient location in the heart of town.

Address ~ 10663 N. Bay Shore Dr., Sister Bay

Lure

This cozy, yet casual fine-dining seafood and steak eatery is located right in the heart of Sister Bay. Lure has intimate booths for private romantic dining and cozy outside seating. It features a rotating menu filled with delicious dishes made with local ingredients.

Although Lure is known for its locally sourced seafood and amazing steaks it also offers vegetarian and gluten-free choices. Lure also boasts that it has one of the best Wisconsin Old Fashioneds in Door County.

If you are looking for an unforgettable evening out on the town as well as amazing food and unique cocktails stop in and check out Lure.

Address ~ 10627 N Bay Shore Dr., Sister Bay

Boathouse on the Bay

Boathouse on the Bay Restaurant is located right on the water with stunning views of Sister Bay and its surrounding area. Inside this cozy eatery, guests will find an elegant atmosphere. The plush chairs and chandeliers create a unique setting perfect for couples.

Their menu includes a variety of seafood dishes such as crabcakes, salmon, and more. The lobster roll and shrimp po’boy are customer favorites. Whether you are celebrating something special or looking for a romantic night out together Boathouse on the Bay is sure to make your Door County trip something to remember.

Address ~ 10716 N. Bay Shore Dr., Sister Bay

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza is a truly unique and fun restaurant that offers a variety of delicious wood-fired pizzas and other Italian specialties that are sure to please even the most discerning palate. With its charming atmosphere and stunning views of Sister Bay, Wild Tomato Wood Fired Pizza & Grill is an excellent choice for couples looking for something casual and fun.

Wild Tomato Wood Fired Pizza & Grill is located right on Sister Bay’s waterfront promenade. The restaurant features an outdoor seating area, with planters of tomatoes and herbs, where guests can take in spectacular views and enjoy the aroma of the growing plants, while they dine. Inside, guests will find a warm and inviting atmosphere with comfortable booths and charming decor that sets the mood for romance.

The menu at Wild Tomato boasts a wide selection of wood-fired pizzas, pasta, salads, and sandwiches made from locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their specialty pizza offerings include classic favorites like Margherita or Prosciutto di Parma as well as more creative options such as their Spinach Artichoke Pie.

Address ~ 10677 N. Bay Shore Dr., Sister Bay

We’ve had many romantic weekends in Door County. Each one of them was so much fun. We are constantly finding new favorites and hidden gems. Sister Bay in Door County comes alive on New Years Even with a cherry drop and during the summer vacationers head to Door County for Cherry Picking.

Chop

Chop is a unique steakhouse and wine bar restaurant that offers a variety of delicious dishes made from locally-sourced ingredients that are sure to please even the most discerning palate.

Chop is located right on Sister Bay’s waterfront promenade and features an outdoor seating area where you can take in spectacular views of Sister Bay while you dine.

Inside you’ll find a warm and inviting atmosphere with comfortable booths and charming decor that sets the mood for romance.

The menu at Chop boasts a wide selection of dishes made from locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their specialty offerings include classic favorites such as steaks, crispy duck, or grilled salmon as well as more creative options such as their wild mushroom risotto or pan-seared scallops. We’ve heard customers remark that Chop has the best breadbasket in Door County.

Address ~ 2345 Mill Rd., Sister Bay

Fat Belly

This quaint restaurant has limited indoor seating but also has a deck with additional outdoor seating. It’s a little bit of a drive from the center of town, but the 5-minute drive is so worth it.

When you see the sign with upside-down animals you know you are in the right place. Feel free to ask why the animals on the sign are upside down. It’s a story they will gladly share with you.

The sign outside says Fat Belly ~ Bowl – Buritto – Beer. Their specialty is burritos and burrito bowls which you can customize to your liking. Everything is made from scratch and to your liking. My daughter is vegetarian and it was an ideal place for us to eat.

The menu says to choose a bowl or burrito, then pick your protein, pick a style, grab a fork, and enjoy, it’s that easy and that amazing!

All ingredients are sourced from local farmers and businesses when possible. This seems to be a wonderful practice in Door County. Stay local and it’s always fresh. Yum!

When you are in Sister Bay don’t hesitate to drive those couple of minutes to get to Fat Belly. Your belly will thank you!

Address ~10621 N. Highland Rd., Sister Bay

Pasta Vino

This cozy family-owned Italian restaurant serves up delicious pasta dishes and offers an extensive selection of wines. With its inviting atmosphere and stunning views of Sister Bay, Pasta Vino is an excellent choice for couples.

Pasta Vino offers an unforgettable dining experience. Inside, you will find a warm and inviting atmosphere with comfortable booths and charming decor that sets the mood for romance.

The menu features classic Italian fare such as handmade pasta made from locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Choose from favorites like Fettuccine Alfredo or try one of their signature dishes like Lobster Ravioli or Porcini Mushroom Risotto.

Address ~ 10571 Country Walk Ln., Sister Bay

All of our Sister Bay’s Restaurant locations can be found on this google map.

Husby’s Food and Spirits

Husby’s Food and Spirits is a fun and unforgettable dining experience for couples. With its indoor and outdoor lively atmosphere, delicious food, and convenient location, this Sister Bay eatery is sure to make your vacation one to remember.

From burgers and fries, taco salads, deep-fried cheese curds, and a menu of American comfort food, you’re sure to find something that will satisfy even the pickiest palate! Whether you’re looking for a fun romantic evening out or just want a casual night out on the town, Husby’s Food and Spirits has what you are looking for.

Be sure to stop in the bar area and enjoy the live bands and try your luck at getting your dollar bill to stick to the ceiling.

Address ~ 10641 N Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay

Crain’s Kitchen

Crain’s Kitchen is a casual restaurant ideal for lunch and early dinner. Crain’s Kitchen was opened by Crain at the age of 60. He says the restaurant allows him to do what he loves best, and that is cooking.

The menu at Crain’s Kitchen features roasted meats, sandwiches on freshly baked biscuits, and soups with a southwestern flavor. What they do they do well!

If you and your sweetie are looking for a casual evening with a little southwestern flair check out Crain’s.

Address ~ 10635 N Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay

Thyme Restaurant & Catering

The clean, modern, sleek look of Thyme Restaurant is inviting and relaxing. The brand-new bar and restaurant features indoor dining, a bar, and classic outdoor seating. This is an ideal place for an intimate evening.

Thymes’ classic menu is refreshing, using only the freshest ingredients, sourced locally when available. Their menu includes flatbread pizzas, burgers, or main dishes such as risotto and pecan-crusted salmon.

If you are looking for something more intimate Thyme will cater off-premises.

Address ~ 10339 N Hwy 57, Sister Bay

Door County Creamery

Door County Creamery is charming. It opened its door in 2013 in downtown Sister Bay. This opening was a longtime dream of a young couple, Jesse and Rachael. (Read their story)

The Creamery is a goat cheese-making facility, eatery, and retail store. In addition to their unique menu, they sell cheeses, soap, and goat’s milk gelato.

The Door County Creamery menu consists of over-the-top one-of-a-kind sandwiches and wraps, homemade soups, cheese, and wine in a truly unique setting ideal for couples.

Address ~ 10653 N Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay

Sister Bay Bowl

Sister Bay Bowl is a family-owned Wisconsin nightclub with a twist. At Sister Bay Bowl you can get dinner and bowling entertainment. You can also work off those calories by bowling after dinner.

Sister Bay Bowl is casual dining at its best, with additional outside patio seating available in the summer.

Sister Bay Bowl’s menu includes what Wisconsin Supper Clubs are known for, good food, a fun atmosphere, and friendly locals. They are known for their Friday fish fry and breaded shrimp.

This is the place where you don’t just stop in for a quick bite to eat, you grab a drink and talk with old or new friends while you wait for your table. You don’t rush through your meal, you enjoy it. And when you are finished you are welcome to stay while and enjoy some more conversation.

Address ~ 10640 N. Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay

McEvoy’s Culinaria Deli

Although McEvoy’s Culinaria Deli is not a traditional sit-down restaurant, there is seating available for something quick. How does a Door County picnic sound? It sounds perfect to us as long as we make a stop at McEvoy’s Culinaria Deli first.

McEvoy’s menu is extensive. Main dishes, such as lasagna, shepherd’s pie, chicken enchiladas, red wine beef pot roast and so much more are available. As well as made-to-order sandwiches and hot or cold paninis. Try their soups or chili, made from scratch in-house. You’ll also want to try their deli salads and pastas.

They are all about the Door County lifestyle and make it easy to grab what you need for a day on the water, a hike, an outdoor theatre, or a romantic picnic while you enjoy Sister Bay.

Roots Inn and Kitchen

Roots Inn is a seasonal restaurant located in a beautiful historic hotel building that feels secluded yet is just steps from the beach.

Roots works with local farmers to source produce used to plan delicious plant-based, vegan comfort food. In addition to vegan-friendly meals, gluten-free food along with farm-raised meats are popular menu choices.

Roots’ menu includes tacos, specialty salads, wings, and their oh-so-delicious truffle chips.

A meal served on the Roots deck is so romantic and the ideal lunch for those needing something special.

Address ~ 2378 Maple Dr., Sister Bay

Zero Sum

Zero Sum is open year-round and offers an entirely gluten-free breakfast and lunch menu. Everything is made fresh, in-house, and from scratch. The atmosphere is quiet, relaxing, and friendly.

Zero Sum is your go-to place for healthy choices for anyone needing or wanting gluten-free options. The food is so good that everyone is impressed by its quality and taste.

The menu offers breakfast smoothies, granola bowls, chia pudding, muffins, waffles, Acai bowls, green bowls, quiche and so much more. So grab your sweetie and enjoy a relaxing, healthy time together.

Address ~ 10578 Country Walk Drive #30, Sister Bay

Sister Bay Restaurants ~ Pubs

Sister Bay does not roll up the sidewalks just because the sun goes down. Restaurants and pubs add to the appeal of visiting one of Wisconsin’s ideal vacation places for adults on a romantic getaway.

Stabbur Scandinavian Beer Garden

Stabbur Scandinavian Beer Garden was created by Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant in the space next door. The building was constructed from the leftover logs from the construction of Al Johnson’s. In addition to the log building, Stabbur’s consists of a unique outdoor bar and large green space making this a truly unique place for couples to hang out.

The over-21 crowds can enjoy drinks, food, and games. The outdoor bar and restaurant area is filled with green space, picnic tables and pergolas.

The menu included Swedish foods such as loaded mac and cheese, grilled brie and turkey with lingonberries, and Swedish shrimp rolls. To round up your meal Stabbur has a constantly changing menu of draft beers and specialty cocktails.

While waiting for your meal this outdoor beer garden is a fun place for couples to round out their day in Sister Bay. It’s a great place to catch the local game on their giant HD TVs or have a little fun on the grounds playing Jenga or goat ring toss.

Address ~ 10698 N. Bay Shore Dr., Sister Bay

Peach Barn Farmhouse and Brewery

Peach Barn Farmhouse and Brewery is open seasonally. This waterfront pub is a cozy and fun place for couples to kick back and enjoy a drink while reminiscing about your day spent together and the night that lays ahead.

Try one of their locally crafted delicious beers or gluten-free hard seltzers while you relax in their indoor taproom or their beautiful landscaped outdoor space while you enjoy the live music and entertainment.

Address ~ 2450 S Bay Shore Dr., Sister Bay

Sister Bay Restaurants ~ Breakfast & Lunch

They say breakfast is the most important meal of the day. Every bit should be enjoyed and savored. Even with so many things to do in Door County, slowing down and savoring life come naturally here.

Carroll House Restaurant

This family-owned restaurant offers indoor and outdoor dining, comfort food, and an amazing breakfast. The chic décor is warm and inviting.

Carroll House’s menu is extensive offering daily specials, but they may be best known for the waffles.

No trip to Sister Bay is complete without trying the incredible stuffed cherry cream cheese waffles. My mouth is watering just remembering these.

Carroll House is a wonderful place for any couple to sit, enjoy coffee and a delicate huge plate of stuffed waffles or pancakes while planning the day ahead.

Address ~ 2445 S. Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay

Sister Bay Restaurants ~ Coffee & Dessert

Wisconsin is known for its beautiful landscapes and small-town charm. If you’re looking for a romantic breakfast or coffee, Sister Bay has a diverse selection available!

Goose and Twigs Coffee Shop

Goose and Twigs is a great place to start your day or relax mid-afternoon after some sightseeing. This popular breakfast spot is known for being a great place for couples to grab a special coffee drink and a quick bite to eat.

Goose and Twigs is casual, cozy, and romantic.

Address ~ 2322 Mill Road, Sister Bay

Skip Stone Coffee

Skip Stone Coffee is a year-round coffee shop that serves its own coffee blend that is roasted locally in Door County.

The charming atmosphere of barn wood and chandeliers from France puts an instant smile on your face as you walk into Skip Stone Coffee. When you follow that smile with the smell of fresh coffee and bakery, you know you are in the right place.

Skip Stone Coffee also offers fresh-baked pastries and other breakfast items using fresh ingredients sourced locally. Beer and wine are served also.

Address ~ 10678 N. Bay shore Dr., Sister Bay

Analog Ice Cream and Coffee

If you are an early bird and are excited about starting your romantic day in Sister Bay with your sweetie then Analog Coffee and Ice Cream is the place to start the day. This charming and welcoming coffee shop opens with the sun.

This seasonal coffee shop features some of the best coffee drinks and espresso in Sister Bay. Homemade bakery, quiche, breakfast burritos, turnovers, and muffins will have your mouth watering.

They also serve Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream. This is your vacation, why not live a little and add a scoop of ice cream to your morning turnover?

Address ~ 10649 N. Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay

Door County Ice Cream Factory & Sandwiches

Established in 1992, Door County Ice Cream with its old-school feel is the perfect place to stop and grab a nice cold treat during a long day of fun and sun.

This Sister Bay gem serves only the best ice cream, made right in Door County. With flavors such as, Door County Cherry, Death Door Chocolate, Sticky Bun, and Harley Davidson just to name a few. If you are looking for the perfect cone, sundae, shake, or ice cream soda this is where you want to go.

Order your ice cream and pull up a seat, indoors or outdoors this charming ice cream factory is a fun place to stop to get a taste of Door County.

Address ~ 11051 State Hwy 42, Sister Bay

Conclusion

From classic American cuisine to upscale gourmet restaurants, Sister Bay has something for everyone. Whether you are searching for a romantic seafood dinner or a casual evening out, Sister Bay has a variety of restaurants to choose from.

There is nothing ordinary about Sister Bay in Door County, Wisconsin. This is where you go to get away from it all. You go to relax, have fun, enjoy nature, tour a lighthouse, or spend the day on the water.

Sister Bay Restaurants are no different, they are locally owned and they support the surrounding dairy farms for the freshest ingredients and use fresh fish right off the boats. Don’t expect the ordinary menu, Sister Bay Restaurants are where you find extraordinary.

If I had my say we would be visiting them all every time we visit Door County.

PIN the list to share with a friend